There are some baby and toddler gifts on most of the theme/motif pages too (dinos, unicorns, etc). Below are some of my favorite books and toys that didn't fit into one of those categories.
I adore this book and probably read it 100 times to each of my kids and gave is as a gift dozens of times : )
Emma Dodd has created a massive series of these cozy, touching animal parent and baby themed books. They are all gorgeous! Check out her whole collection here.
These are neat bath books that magically get colored in when they're dipped in water
This spinning gear toy is so fun for babies up through much bigger kids (heck, I find it kind of theraputic to thread one of these on and watch it spin down ; )